In a society that prioritizes consensus, Shintaro Ishihara chose controversy. His death early this month was marked around the world with obituaries that singled the former Tokyo governor out as "notorious" (Financial Times), an "intense nationalist" and "firebrand" (The New York Times), and a "politician who peddled hatred" (Asia Times).
Some of these comments are undoubtedly deserved, the inevitable legacy of a man who went on record as saying that he wished to die a hated figure. Churchill’s famous words come to mind: "Show me a man without enemies and I will show you a man who has never stood for anything."
But as a non-Japanese who came to know him in his later years, I remember a man very different from the ranting nationalist portrayed in the world’s media.
With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.