Regarding Philip Brasor's Feb. 8 Media Mix article, "New law may backfire on victims": Sometimes it seems that many people have forgotten that a trial has a two parts: First, the defendant is found innocent or guilty; then, if guilty, punishment is imposed. This is supposed to be true in Japan, just as in most other countries that follow Western-style jurisprudence.
However, it appears that the new law is being implemented in a way that confuses the two phases — by letting victims or family members contribute during the first phase. Unless victims or family members were a witness to a crime, they shouldn't have a formal role during the first phase. Only after someone is found guilty of the crime would it be appropriate to bring in a victim to point out the impact on his or her family.
And even then, as Brasor points out, bringing victims into a trial may not have the intended impact. However, if they are to be part of a trial, victims or their families should participate only after the accused has been confirmed as the guilty party.
With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.