Spike Lee has made so many didactic movies in his career that it wouldn't have surprised me if his latest — "Miracle at St. Anna," which looks at a squad of black G.I.s fighting the Nazis in World War II — was yet another. What did surprise me, though, was that this time around Spike decided to mix his didacticism with a splash of fizzy magic realism.
Now those two angles seem about as compatible as black-turbaned sourpuss Ayatollah Khamenei and fun-loving AV queen Maria Ozawa. Magic realism is best known for its fuzzy feel-good vibe and cloying quirkiness (a la "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" or "Chocolat"); didacticism, on the other hand, is known for hammer-to-head point-scoring and strident affirmation of right and wrong (a la "Michael Clayton" or "Valkyrie"). Magic realism relies on coincidence and miracles, didacticism on real-world argument and reason.
Lee tries to split the difference in "Miracle at St. Anna," and the results are a bit of a muddle. Set in Tuscany in 1944 after the allied offensive in Italy had turned into a long, hard slog, Lee's film mixes the war-is-hell realism of "Saving Private Ryan" with the quaint and colorful Italianismo of "Cinema Paradiso."
With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.